In the pocket universe created to imprison him, Superman realises that his other self has the upper hand and that any hope of escape is probably futile.
Back in the sixth dimension the heroes are called to a meeting by Martian Manhunter and Hawkgirl to hear how there is something very wrong about this utopian world they have found themselves. Shayne J’onzz is about to share with them what he knows when the sixth dimension version of Superman intervenes to prevent him.
He reveals himself to be a being called the World Forger and tells them that they have a choice to make. The battle that they “won” here relied on them saving only those who had not chosen the side of Doom that Lex and his Legion would be offering the world in the next few days.
Meanwhile back on Earth, Starman, Mera and Starro suddenly realise that Mr. Mxyzptlk is not imagining things into reality, but is instead is un-imagining everything in existence!
In the Sixth Dimension, the league discuss the choice they are being asked to make and all decide to fight and save everybody, except Batman who says that ever since the Barbatos they have been fighting losing war, taking one step forward and two steps backwards. Maybe it was time they stopped clinging to hope so futilely. Wonder Woman replies that if Superman was here he would never agree to a world where only the good where saved.
And so, the league make their decision and with that, World Forger transports them to a prison on Apokolips where all the bad people are being held in this dimension. They are greeted by a squad of guards and their leader reveals herself to be none other than Lois Lane!