Superman takes Wonder Woman and Batman to his Fortress and tells them about the last events in his life: his battle against Mister Mxyzptlk, where it was revealed he was split, and how he is whole again and the universe has been changed. He also talks about several unsettling, recurring dreams where he is attacked by his younger self, who wants to get his life back. In said dreams, both Supermen brawl until Bruce and Diana step between them and calm them down.
Batman and Wonder Woman are visibly disturbed by those revelations. Diana sympathizes with Clark, but Bruce find Clark’s story hard to believe and asks who else knows. Clark tells only his family knows: Lois and Jon were there, and he told Kara. Bruce advises to keep it that way for the present time, until they know something else about their mysterious enemy capable of altering reality at will. After a brief debate, the trio of heroes agree.